Stanley Renshon's blog

A National Immigration Auction, Part I: A Very Bad Idea

By Stanley Renshon, September 16, 2010

The latest conventional wisdom about reforming America's immigration policies takes the form of touting "skill-based immigration." An extreme example in point is a New York Times op-ed this week entitled "Foreign Stimulus." In their proposal, the authors Pia Orrenius and Madeline Zavody argue that our current immigration system be replaced with a national auction for both skilled and unskilled labor. Read more...

Immigration and the New Congress: Opportunity Knocks

By Stanley Renshon, September 14, 2010

Politico is up with a story whose title's obviousness, "Midterms imperil immigration bill," belies its importance. The story estimates that as many as 17 Senate seats of those who voted at one point or another for "comprehensive immigration reform" and amnesty would change hands. Read more...

What 'Strong Anti-immigrant Tilt'?

By Stanley Renshon, September 14, 2010

The Los Angeles Times reported yesterday on the latest Quinnipiac University national survey on American opinions about various immigration matters. Read more...

The Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part VI: Why Did the Number of Illegal Immigrants Decline?

By Stanley Renshon, September 12, 2010

At the heart of the Pew report is its estimate that the number of illegal immigrants in the United States has declined by approximately 900,000 persons. For purposes of this entry, we accept that figure to ask why, exactly, the number of illegal immigrants might have declined. Read more...

The Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part V: Beyond the Headlines

By Stanley Renshon, September 10, 2010

At the heart of the Pew report is the claim that, to the extent the statistical estimates and weighting are correct, the overall estimated numbers of illegal immigrants in the United States has declined. At least, that is what the Pew report's title suggests is its most noteworthy finding. And it is point that almost all news accounts emphasize. Read more...

Behind the Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part IV: The Mystery of the Missing 900,000 Illegal Immigrants

By Stanley Renshon, September 8, 2010

At the heart of the Pew report is the finding that the overall estimated numbers of illegal immigrants in the United States have declined from a peak of 12 million to 11.1 million, a net decline of 900,000 illegal immigrants. At least, this is what the report's title suggests that Pew believes is its most noteworthy finding. The decline is also the point that almost all accounts of the Pew report emphasize. Read more...

Behind the Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part III: Estimating Illegal Immigration - The Basic Model and Its Limitations

By Stanley Renshon, September 7, 2010

The basic approach of both the recent Pew report and those of the Department of Homeland Security in estimating the number of illegal immigrants currently in the United States is based on the "residual method" and seems, on first glance to be quite straightforward. Read more...

Behind the Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part II: How Many Illegals?

By Stanley Renshon, September 5, 2010

The recently released Pew report on the decline of the illegal population in the United States has garnered a lot of attention, though a great deal of it for the wrong reasons. Obama administration officials are already touting their policies to account for the decline. Read more...

Behind the Pew Study on Illegal Immigration, Part I: First the 'Good' News

By Stanley Renshon, September 3, 2010

The new report from the Pew Hispanic Center is certain to be widely discussed and widely misunderstood. The report delivers the conclusion most likely to be quoted in its title, "U.S. Unauthorized Immigration Flows Are Down Sharply Since Mid-Decade." Read more...

Paradigm Shift: Updating Immigration Policy's 'Conventional Wisdom'

By Stanley Renshon, August 26, 2010

The philosopher of science Thomas Kuhn revolutionized his field with the 1962 publication of a seminal book, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. In it he argued that science, no less than other forms of human effort, proceeded on the basis of its own received beliefs. These beliefs formed the foundation of what was deemed acceptable scientific practice and provided as well the basic framework for examining science's results. Read more...

Breaking Immigration Policy's Spiral of Silence

By Stanley Renshon, August 25, 2010

Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann, a specialist in German public opinion research, published a book in 1984 with the University of Chicago Press, entitled The Spiral of Silence. In it, she tried to understand why ordinary Germans had not been more vocal in their opposition to the gradual rise and consolidation of Hitler's regime. Read more...

Immigration Policy and the Real 'Two Americas'

By Stanley Renshon, August 24, 2010

It is easy to get into trouble when you divide this vast, diverse country into two dichotomous parts and claim that distinction explains something enormously significant. Read more...

Ross Douthat's Two Americas

By Stanley Renshon, August 23, 2010

The usually sensible New York Times columnist Ross Douthat careens into a conceptual immigration ditch in trying to divide Americans into those who welcome immigrants as long as they profess allegiance to this country's iconic creedal ideals and those who "often strikes cruder, more xenophobic notes." In two different entries last week – "Islam in Two Americas" and "Assimilation and Nativism" – he made an unfortunate and ill-founded distinction between those for whom "allegiance to the Constitution trumps ethnic differences, language barriers and religious divides" and those who expect "new arrivals to assimilate themselves to these norms, and quickly" and one might add "or else"! Read more...

No Amnesty, No Border Security? The Questionable Premises of an Immigration Grand Bargain

By Stanley Renshon, June 22, 2010

Reports this past weekend depict a brutally frank exchange between President Obama and Sen. John Kyl (R-AZ) about border control and amnesty legislation. Kyl reports that in a one-on-one meeting with the president they discussed securing the border in the context of pending legislation to enact "comprehensive immigration reform." Kyl reports the president as saying, "The problem is, . . . Read more...

This Just in!! President Reagan Endorses Enforcement-First Immigration Policy

By Stanley Renshon, June 17, 2010

"What would the Gipper do" is a question that some Republicans ask when they don't understand how, exactly, to apply Ronald Reagan's core character and worldview to the problems that America faces today. The result is a search for one or more "truths" to validate the author's speculations regarding what Reagan would have done relying on a direct extrapolation of America's circumstances in 1986, almost a quarter of a century ago, to those today. Read more...

The Democrats' New Immigration Strategy: Euphemism

By Stanley Renshon, June 14, 2010

eu•phe•mism
Noun (from the Greek euphēmismos, from euphēmos auspicious, sounding good.)
1: the substitution of an agreeable or inoffensive expression for one that may offend or suggest something unpleasant.

Politico recently reported that the Democrats have come up with a tough new immigration strategy. It consists of "talking like Republicans"! Read more...

Moral Myopia at the Arizona Border

By Stanley Renshon, June 10, 2010

The Washington Post recently ran a story about Shura Wallin, an immigration activist who, with her group of 140 volunteers who call themselves Los Samaritanos, assist illegal immigrants making the potentially hazardous trip across the Sonoran Desert. Read more...