Although once-upon-a-time all immigrants were self-starters, only a tiny minority of legal immigrants now are in this category – all because of our peculiar immigration policies.
As promised in a previous blog here is some information on this interesting subset of immigrants.
Most immigrants are non-self-starters, being nominated by U.S. residents, or U.S. employers, and in a smaller number of cases being linked with U.S. refugee resettlement organizations. Tiny groups – ex-U.S. employees abroad, for instance -- are nominated by our government. The self-starter definition is my own, and is based on government documents, but the U.S. government does not make this distinction; it is unlikely to do so, as it would cast some doubts on our current immigrant-selection system.
In fiscal year 2008, the Department of Homeland Security recorded the award of the green card to
1,107,126 individuals, some of whom were newly arrived, and some of whom were living in the U.S. and were adjusted from some other category to that of permanent resident alien. The source is the DHS annual Yearbook of Immigration Statistics.
Of that number, a mere 124,291 were self-starters, that is only 11.2% of the total.
Among the approximately 300 legal immigrant categories shown in table 7 of the above-cited report, I found only five groups that could be called self-starters, these are: the asylees, the diversity (or visa lottery) holders, ministers of religion, other religious workers, and investors; the principals in these groups and their spouses and children who arrived with them constitute the 124,291 total.
Asylees are much like refugees, in that they are said to be fleeing tyranny or some other catastrophe, but they are in the U.S. either legally or illegally, and their claims to asylum status are screened either by DHS officials or by immigration judges. (Refugees are screened overseas by U.S. agents.) The diversity program – surely the most easily disposable part of the system – is for those who win the visa lottery. They must be citizens of a nation which does not send us many immigrants, and have a high school diploma or its equivalent.
Investors must agree to put some money into job-creation efforts in the U.S.; this is a program that had been abused in the past. The two religious classifications are probably included as the result of the lobbying of the Catholic Church, and the declining interest in Americans in becoming priests and nuns. Non-Catholics can be admitted as well.
The numbers in each of these groups in FY 2008, and their average family size, which I calculated from the DHS data, are shown below:
Category | 2008 Green Card Awards | Avg. Family Size |
Self-starters | ||
Asylees | 76,362 | 1.90 |
Diversity/Visa Lottery | 41,761 | 1.87 |
Ministers | 2,566 | 2.16 |
Other religious workers | 2,242 | 1.77 |
Investors | 1,360 | 3.11 |
In comparison, two groups of U.S.-nominated Immigrants | ||
1980 Refugee Act refugees | 90,030 | 2.70 |
Brothers and Sisters of citizens | 68,859 | 2.46 |
Source: 2008 Yearbook of Immigration Statistics, Table 7 |